Preserving History and Honor: Is It Acceptable to Knock Over Confederate Soldier Gravestones?
Recent conversations and controversies surrounding Confederate statues have sparked debates about what should be done with these memorials. However, another common yet less discussed issue is the physical destruction of Confederate soldier gravestones. While Confederate statues are often the focus of civil rights and historical preservation discussions, forgetful individuals sometimes target the markers found in cemeteries.
Legal and Ethical Considerations
The act of knocking over or damaging Confederate soldier gravestones is not only unethical but also illegal in many jurisdictions. For example, in Illinois, removing or defacing more than 20 gravestones could garner a class three felony conviction, leading to a fine of $25,000 or more and mandatory reparations to the cemetery. Similar laws are likely present in other states.
Respecting Historical Figures
One might wonder if destroying the physical markers of Confederate soldiers is justifiable if some of these individuals were indeed racists or fascists. However, most Confederate soldiers were simply defending their homes against what they perceived as a hostile invasion. This perspective suggests that simply knowing someone fought for the Confederacy does not automatically label them as a racist or fascist.
Ethical Obligations and Respect for the Dead
Just as one would not destroy the grave markers of their family members, even if those family members engaged in actions that society now deems reprehensible, it would be equally disrespectful to destroy the graves of Confederate soldiers. Such actions dehumanize individuals and perpetuate the exact same prejudices they aim to undermine. Furthermore, a society that consistently erases or destroys its history risks repeating past mistakes.
Erasing History vs. Learning from It
The destruction of history, whether it be statues or gravestones, serves only to obscure the truth and prevent proper understanding. Instead of destroying these markers, it is more productive to learn from them and ensure that future generations are informed about the complexities of history, including how perceived injustices sometimes led to armed conflict.
Scientific and Biological Truths
From a biological standpoint, there is an overwhelming amount of evidence that demonstrates the inherent humanity of all individuals. For instance, research in the Human Genome Project has shown that humans share more than 99.9% of their DNA. Additionally, the use of DNA profiling in courts has proven to be a highly accurate method in determining individual identity, highlighting the fundamental genetic unity of all humans.
Moreover, the skin functions not only as a protective organ but also as a means of regulating exposure to sunlight. Loss of primary skin functions can be fatal, whereas a lack of melanin, which provides sun protection, can lead to serious health issues and social ostracism. This underscores the biological and social equality of all human beings.
Indeed, the Truth Matters
By understanding that all people share such vast genetic similarities, we can overcome the barriers that racism and prejudice create. Embracing such truths is crucial to moving forward and ensuring that societies no longer perpetuate harmful stereotypes and classifications based on appearance.
Conclusion
In conclusion, it is not acceptable to destroy Confederate soldier gravestones. Such actions not only violate legal standards but also stand as a form of historical revisionism that defies the complex narrative of our past. By preserving these graves, we honor and respect the individuals buried within, and by studying these markers, we can work towards a more informed and enlightened future.